You open the next episode of The Bible expecting a family drama. Maybe some sibling tension.
But within five lines, it’s a murder mystery. The firstborn child in human history becomes the first killer. The second-born becomes the first corpse.
And the motive? Jealousy… over God’s approval. Or so that’s what the established narrative claims.
But here’s the twist: the script feels rushed. Motivations are vague. The Lord is playing favorites.
And Cain—yes, Cain—starts to feel like the character who maybe just got the worst edit.
Missed the previous assignment? No problem.
We’re discussing Genesis 4, where jealousy turns deadly,
and the first family drama ends in exile.
You can read that section here: https://biblehub.com/niv/genesis/4.htm
The Sacrificial Edit
Cain and Abel both make offerings. Abel’s is accepted. Cain’s is not.
No explanation given.
Cue audience confusion: Was Cain’s offering actually bad? Or was this a setup? Producer favoritism, maybe? God as the showrunner giving Abel the hero edit?
Or maybe this isn’t about quality… it’s about genre.
Cain brought produce. Abel brought blood.
What if Cain showed up with romcom set dec to a slasher flick—when the script called for gore?
Does God Want Blood?
This moment sets a disturbing tone: blood is rewarded, fruit is rejected.
That choice echoes through the entire Old Testament — from animal sacrifices to Abraham’s near-sacrifice of Isaac. It raises a chilling question: Is this God fueled by love… or blood?And if so, what exactly is this entity demanding sacrifice really after?
More on that in future episodes…
Cain’s Confessional
Cain starts looking less like a villain… and more like a supporting character who just got sidelined in his own show.
His conversation with God reads like a therapy session—or a producer trying to talk down an actor who’s about to walk off set.
“Sin is crouching at your door,” says the Lord.
But Cain walks out anyway. Was that a warning… or bait?
Listen to the podcast episode here.
The Original Cancelation
Cain kills Abel. No witnesses. No bodicam. Just a field.
And a question from God: “Where is your brother?”
Cain shrugs: “Am I my brother’s keeper?”
Maybe it’s snark. Or maybe… it’s sincere. Maybe he’s asking:
“Was that supposed to be my job?”
Then comes the twist: God doesn’t kill Cain. He marks him.
And declares: Anyone who kills Cain will suffer vengeance sevenfold.
The number 7 shows up everywhere in the Hebrew Bible. It means completion. Structure. Divine order.
So this isn’t just a threat—it’s a seal.
Cain may be exiled… but he’s still under contract.
Translation Trouble: A Word Can Kill
Genesis 4:7 is a prime example of how one line can shift meaning:
KJV: “If thou doest well, shalt thou not be accepted?”
NIV: “If you do what is right, will you not be accepted?”
ESV: “If you do well, will you not be accepted?”
The tone jumps from ominous to encouraging to passive-aggressive dad.
And the image of “sin crouching at your door?” Is it a metaphor? Or could something literally be crouching at the door, awaiting an invitation?
Time Jumps & Ghost Writers
Next thing you know, Cain has a wife. A city. A whole genealogy.
Wait—where did these people come from?
This is the first real break in continuity. A time jump. Or maybe a merge of scripts from different traditions.
Genesis doesn’t slow down to explain. It keeps moving.
One moment we’re in the fallout of a murder. The next, we’re in the spin-off: Cain’s Lineage.
Maybe Genesis is stitching together two competing myths—Cain’s line vs. Seth’s line—like rival studio canons fighting for screen time.
Final Take — The First Murder Was a Rewrite
Cain’s story doesn’t read like pure villainy.
It reads like someone trying to make sense of why violence showed up in the human story so soon.
Maybe the first murder was more than a tragedy. Maybe it was a rewrite.
And if the firstborn child of humanity was edited into a scapegoat… What else is being edited?
We’ll keep reading.
This Week’s Reading Assignment
Genesis 5–6
Giants walk the earth, the heavens start whispering, and the floodgates of judgment creak open.
Why this version? We’re reading from the NIV — New International Version because it’s easy to read, still close to the original, and basically the industry standard.
See you next week!
Further Reading & Receipts
Welcome to the paper trail.
Links sometimes break over time—that’s the nature of the web...and censorship. If you run into one that’s missing, feel free to let me know in the comments or by messaging me. We’re building a living archive together.
Many of the sources and backups are being preserved in The Vault, an exclusive archive for paid subscribers.
Cain & Abel — Interpretations and Symbolism
“Rivalry Among Brothers” – The Bible Project (podcast)
https://bibleproject.com/podcast/rivalry-among-brothers/Jewish Encyclopedia entry on Cain: historical and mystical interpretations
https://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/3903-cain
Blood Sacrifice & Divine Favoritism
“Why Do You Think God Rejected Cain’s Offering?” – TheTorah.com
https://www.thetorah.com/article/cains-im-penitent-response-to-his-punishmentBritannica: sacrifice – Religious Ritual (includes history of blood and grain offerings)
https://www.britannica.com/topic/sacrifice-religion
Symbolism of the Number 7 in the Hebrew Bible
“Is There Any Significance to the Number Seven?” – Chabad.org
https://www.chabad.org/therebbe/letters/default_cdo/aid/963127/jewish/The-Significance-of-the-Number-Seven.htmOverview of biblical numerology and meaning of 7 from BibleStudy.org
https://www.biblestudy.org/bibleref/meaning-of-numbers-in-bible/7.html
Translation Variants & Interpretive Impact
Genesis 4:3–7 Side-by-Side Translation Comparison Tool (BibleHub)
https://biblehub.com/parallel/genesis/4-7.htm“Every Word Matters: Why Your Bible Translation Matters” – Lifeway Research
https://research.lifeway.com/2017/06/29/every-word-matters/
Cain’s Wife & Ancient Genealogy Gaps
“Where Did Cain Get His Wife?” — Biologos (a solid, science-friendly theological take)
https://discourse.biologos.org/t/cains-wife-and-ofther-humans/36505
Thanks for joining me on The Deeper Read.
If you like where this is going, subscribe to LisaWritesNow on Substack—that’s where you’ll find full transcripts, bonus content, and deeper receipts.
And if you're ready to go further down the rabbit hole...
Season 2 of The Hidden Cut is already in the works, picking up right where this season leaves off.
🎬 Continue the Series
← Previous Episode: Genesis Writers’ Room
→ Next Episode: The Bloodline & The Breach
📂 Full Episode Guide: Cold Open
Subscribe to LisaWritesNow on Substack for fresh cuts, hot takes, and all my latest writing mischief.
Think something got left on the cutting room floor?
Add your notes below—we’re still editing in real time.